| ROBOTIC
SURGERY Fantasy is todays reality Changing
the culture of surgery! One of the
latest technical advances in minimally-invasive surgery is robotic surgery. Minimally-invasive,
laparoscopic surgery has achieved excellent outcomes for patients in reducing
the length of hosptial stays, the need for pain medication, the time needed to
recover from surgery, providing a better cosmetic result. As the next step in
technology, robotic surgery offers all the benefits of laparoscopic surgery along
with the potential for increased precision and effectiveness.
DEFINITION The
word Robot is taken from the Czech robota, meaning forced labor, has
evolved in meaning from dumb machines that perform menial, repetitive tasks to
the highly intelligent anthropomorphic robots of popular culture. Robots
have often been thought of as machines that replace humans. These machines have
been used in manufacturing, space exploration, and other areas. However, they
can also be used as surgical tools. Many people think of these tools as devices
used to replace the physician. However, they are used to complement human surgeons.
The
field of robotics provides an enhancement of human performance, the ability to
project surgical expertise to remote and distant places, and recreation of a patient
in a "virtual" form. Robotics takes the surgeons motions and changes
them into electronic signals which through a computer can be enhanced. The result
is performing a procedure with greater accuracy and precision..
HISTORY The
history of robotics in surgery begins with the Puma 560, a robot used in 1985
by Kwoh et al to perform neurosurgical biopsies with greater precision.[6,11]]
Three years later, Davies et al performed a transurethral resection of the prostate
using the Puma 560.[12] This system eventually led to the development of PROBOT,
a robot designed specifically for transurethral resection of the prostate. ROBODOC,
a robotic system was designed to machine the femur with greater precision in hip
replacement surgeries.[1] ROBODOC was the first surgical robot approved by the
FDA.
The first coronary bypass surgery in a
human patient using robotic arms manipulated by the surgeon was performed by Dr.
Ralph Damiano at the Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, Pennsylvania.
WHAT
IS ROBOTIC SURGICAL SYSTEM ? The robotic surgical system is a computer-enhanced
minimally invasive surgical system consisting of three components:
High-definition
camera providing the surgeon a true, minimally invasive view of the surgical field,
magnified up to 15 times. With this technology, the surgeon can more easily identify
vital anatomy such as the delicate nerves and blood vessels surrounding specific
anatomy.
Surgical cart including the instruments
and three robotic arms whereby the laparoscope and two instruments are inserted.
The instruments are designed to mimic the movement of the surgeon's hands, wrists
and fingers. Their extensive range of motion allows precision that is not available
in standard minimally invasive procedures.
Surgeon
console containing the master controls that the surgeon uses to manipulate the
instruments. The handles or "Masters" translate the surgeon's natural
hand and wrist movements into corresponding, precise and scaled movements. The
instruments are only able to move when commanded by the surgeon.
 Robot
can accomplish what the human surgeon cannot because of its ability to mimic the
human hand within a small, contained space. The EndoWristTM Instruments transform
the surgeons wrists, hand and fingers into tiny instruments. During the
procedure, while the console surgeon operates the sophisticated robot from a distance,
the bedside surgeon is responsible for placement of the correct surgical ports
and directing the robot into the patient.
The da Vinci surgical robot is
the first robotic system licensed for use in American operating rooms. It was
granted FDA approval in 2000. The FDA cleared ZEUS robotic surgical system
in October 2001 to assist in the control of blunt dissectors, retractors, graspers,
and stabilizers during laparo-scopic and thoracoscopic surgeries. BENEFITS
OF ROBOTIC SURGERY Benefits to Patient - Reduced pain and trauma
to the body - Less blood loss and need for transfusions - Less post-operative
pain and discomfort - Less risk of infection - Shorter hospital stay -
Faster recovery and return to work. - Allows for a minimally-invasive approach
in surgery which means much less scarring and improved comesis
Benefits
to surgeon greater precision and dexterity where fine suturing techniques
are required robotic arms eliminate the tremor of a surgeon's hands improved technique
for surgery reduced fatigue during surgery - comfortable seated position at robotic
controls.
 HOW
IS ROBOTIC SURGERY DIFFERENT FROM MINIMALLY INVASIVE SURGERY? Minimally
invasive surgery is a general term for procedures that reduce trauma by performing
operations through small ports rather than large incisions. Minimally invasive
surgery is now a common place for certain procedures. But until now, we havent
been able to use minimally invasive techniques for more complex operations. With
skilled surgeons and the da Vinci Surgical System, we can now use minimally
invasive techniques in even the most complicated procedures. What all a robot
can do for surgeons ? Robotic surgery can, in fact,
be used for a number of procedures within multiple specialties including: general
surgery (i.e. laparoscopic adrenalectomy, gastric bypass) gynecological surgery
(i.e. cystocele repair, hysterectomy, tubal ligation) thoracic surgery (esophagectomy,
lung biopsy, tumor resection) urological surgery (donor nephrectomy, prostatectomy,
and ureter harvest) vascular surgery (aortic abdominal aneurysm and vena cava
tumor) The Challenge and its solution According to the surgeons, the biggest challenge
faced was minimising the "lag" effect if the time delay between
the surgeons and the robot was too long, or slightly out of sync, it would destroy
the timing and "feel" of the surgeons. Experts believe that a time delay
of 330 milliseconds would be the maximum acceptable delay, but thanks to years
of research and development by France Telecom, this was cut down to a mere 150
milliseconds for the operation. The Learning Curve
The
FDA requires manufacturers to train surgeons before they can use robotic surgical
systems on patients. Ogden says there is a significant learning curve involved.
"As it stands now, it takes 12-18 patients before surgeons feel comfortable
and before surgeons are able to perform the procedures as quickly as with standard
techniques," he says. Paul Nolan of Computer Motion says typical training
for surgeons who buy the ZEUS system involves up to 40 hours, including experience
at animal and cadaveric labs. The
Future of Robotic Surgery Robotic surgery is in its infancy. Many obstacles
and disadvantages will be resolved in time and no doubt many other questions will
arise. Many questions have yet to be asked; questions such as malpractice liability,
credentialing, training requirements, and interstate licensing for tele-surgeons,
to name just a few.
Many future "advancements"
are already being researched. Some laboratories, including the authors' laboratory,
are currently working on systems to relay touch sensation from robotic instruments
back to the surgeon. Other laboratories are working on improving current methods
and developing new devices for suture-less anastomoses. When most people think
about robotics, they think about automation. The possibility of automating some
tasks is both exciting and controversial. Future systems might include the ability
for a surgeon to program the surgery and merely supervise as the robot performs
most of the tasks. The possibilities for improvement and advancement are only
limited by imagination and cost.
By providing
the use of a variety of technologies to enhance the capabilities of human surgeons,
robotics will become an increasingly vital component in the medical world. Doctors
of the next century must learn to use this information to complement their capabilities
in order to provide better patient care.
 REFERENCES
Mack, M.J, Minimally Invasive and Robotic Surgery JAMA, 2001; 285: 5.
Schulam, P.G., et al, Telesurgical Mentoring, Surgical Endoscopy, 1997; 11: 1001-1005.
Sackier, J.M., Wang, Y., Robotically Assisted Laparoscopic Surgery, from Concept
to Development, Surgical Endoscopy, 1994; 8. Falcone, T.,
Goldberg, J., Garcia-Ruiz, A., Margossian, H., Stevens, L., Full Robotic
Assistance for Laparoscopic Tubal Anastomosis; First Case Report, Journal of
Laparoendoscopic and Advanced Surgical Techniques, 1999; 9(1): 107-113.
Butner, S.E., Ghodoussi, M., Wang, Y Robotic Surgery - The Transatlantic Case
submitted for publication to 2002 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and
Automation, Washington D.C. |